Unresolved and disagreeing evidence

Supplements (XW_0011)

source_level_recording | 441012 /SPOROPHILA FRONTALIS ... WITH /ATTILA PHOENICURUS ... | supplements | additional bird remains unidentified | No ownership transfer.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Buffy-fronted Seedeater species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-tailed Attila species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Unresolved additional bird (CU_0005)

At least one additional bird remains unidentified. | owner_family_clarification | material | Remain unidentified. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Buffy-fronted Seedeater species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-tailed Attila species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Unidentified additional bird (HRO_0014)

At least one additional bird remains unidentified. | unidentified_additional_bird | not_identified | remain_unidentified | Direct scan support added without replacing original owner/family provenance.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Buffy-fronted Seedeater species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-tailed Attila species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Multiple birds (HRO_0015)

Rufous-tailed Attila plus at least one additional unidentified bird. | multiple_birds | definite | preserve_historical_target_context_and_later_review_separately | Direct scan support added without replacing original owner/family provenance.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Buffy-fronted Seedeater species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-tailed Attila species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Historical versus listening conflict (CU_0002)

Historical designated target is SPOROPHILA FRONTALIS; reported listening identifies Rufous-tailed Attila, a historical contextual species, plus an unknown bird. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | Preserve target, context, and later review separately; no ownership replacement. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Buffy-fronted Seedeater species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-tailed Attila species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0001)

contextual_WITH_species | ATTILA RUFUS | agrees | Preserve contextual historical label and direct scan result separately. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Tentative identification (CU_SCAN_0005)

Basileuterus hypoleucus? is clearly transcribed but explicitly tentative. | handwritten_original | material | Keep identification certainty tentative and transcription certainty clear. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Contextual comment (HRO_SCAN_0005)

Woodquails occur at the end | contextual_comment | not_identified | preserve_as_overlay | Taxonomically unresolved contextual timing comment.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Conflicts (XW_SCAN_0002)

contextual_recording | historical context does not list ATTILA PHOENICURUS | conflicts | No species-account owner created. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Rufous-tailed Attila species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Ambiguous transcription (CU_SCAN_0002)

P1-U13 visibly resembles MC1.mp1; final character remains ambiguous even though reviewed object MC1 is definitely resolved. | transcription | material | Preserve MC1.mp1 diplomatically; keep owner resolution separate. | resolved_mapping_transcription_remains_ambiguous

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Unresolved additional bird (CU_SCAN_0007)

Bellbird is definite; at least one additional bird remains unidentified. | owner_family_clarification | material | Remain unidentified. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bearded Tachuri species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Multiple birds (HRO_SCAN_0018)

Bellbird plus at least one additional bird | multiple_birds | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bearded Tachuri species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Unidentified additional bird (HRO_SCAN_0019)

At least one additional bird is unidentified | unidentified_additional_bird | not_identified | remain_unidentified

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bearded Tachuri species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Historical versus listening conflict (CU_SCAN_0014)

Historical designated POLYSTICTUS PECTORALIS conflicts with scan-supported Bellbird plus an unidentified bird. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | Preserve historical target and human review separately. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bearded Tachuri species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Conflicts (XW_SCAN_0008)

designated_target_species | POLYSTICTUS PECTORALIS | conflicts | Bellbird result does not overwrite historical target. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bearded Tachuri species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Ambiguous transcription (CU_SCAN_0003)

P1-U28 visually resembles 441018; definite owner mapping resolves 441008.mp3. | transcription | material | Preserve 441018 diplomatically; mapping remains separate. | resolved_mapping_transcription_remains_ambiguous

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bearded Tachuri species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0010)

contextual_WITH_species | TURDUS RUFIVENTRIS | agrees | Review confirms contextual relationship. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Historical versus listening conflict (CU_SCAN_0015)

Historical target OREOPHYLAX MOREIRAE is not confirmed; review agrees with contextual TURDUS RUFIVENTRIS. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | Preserve target, context, and review separately. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Itatiaia Thistletail species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-bellied Thrush species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Conflicts (XW_SCAN_0009)

designated_target_species | OREOPHYLAX MOREIRAE | conflicts | Review does not replace target. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Itatiaia Thistletail species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Rufous-bellied Thrush species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Historical versus listening conflict (CU_SCAN_0016)

Historical bird target PENELOPE OBSCURA versus handwritten non-bird result dogs. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | Preserve both layers without overwrite. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Conflicts (XW_SCAN_0011)

designated_target_species | PENELOPE OBSCURA | conflicts | Non-bird result stored separately. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Non bird sound (HRO_SCAN_0016)

dogs | Dogs | non_bird_sound | definite | record_non_bird_sound_without_overwriting_history

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0020)

designated_target_species | PHAETHORNIS EURYNOME | agrees | Historical target retained. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bare-throated Bellbird species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0032)

Dusky-throated Hermit | Dusky-throated Hermit | species_identification | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bare-throated Bellbird species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Checklist pointer label conflict (SWALLOW_TANAGER_GROUP)

51 checklist rows share the same pointer value; 3 are flagged source_conflict=yes.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Swallow-Tanager species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Unresolved additional bird (CU_0003)

At least one additional bird remains unidentified. | owner_family_clarification | material | Remain unidentified. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bare-throated Bellbird species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Supplements (XW_0006)

contextual_recording | MORNING CHORUS; ten WITH taxa | supplements | leave additional bird unidentified | No species owner is inferred.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bare-throated Bellbird species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Unidentified additional bird (HRO_0008)

At least one additional bird remains unidentified. | unidentified_additional_bird | not_identified | remain_unidentified | Direct scan support added without replacing original owner/family provenance.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Bare-throated Bellbird species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Multiple birds (HRO_0009)

Bellbird plus at least one additional unidentified bird. | multiple_birds | definite | contextual_multi_bird_recording | Direct scan support added without replacing original owner/family provenance.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Unresolved additional bird (CU_0004)

At least one additional bird remains unidentified. | owner_family_clarification | material | Remain unidentified; retain historical UNKNOWN CALL status. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Supplements (XW_0007)

unidentified_recording_status | UNKNW4 UNKNOWN CALL | supplements | preserve unidentified status and later Bellbird identification separately | Later identification does not rewrite historical status.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_0008)

unidentified_recording_status | UNKNW4 UNKNOWN CALL | agrees | additional bird remains unidentified | Unresolved component explicit.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Unidentified additional bird (HRO_0011)

At least one additional bird remains unidentified. | unidentified_additional_bird | not_identified | remain_unidentified | Direct scan support added without replacing original owner/family provenance.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Multiple birds (HRO_0012)

Bellbird plus at least one additional unidentified bird. | multiple_birds | definite | preserve_unidentified_contextual_status | Direct scan support added without replacing original owner/family provenance.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Application level unresolved relationship (CU_0006)

Startup physical media asset remains unresolved. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | No species-account link. | unresolved

Application level unresolved relationship (CU_0007)

Historical startup call path remains unrecovered. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | Keep application-level purpose separate. | unresolved

Application level unresolved relationship (CU_0008)

Relationship to the six ordinary Habia rubica recordings remains unresolved. | modern_reconciliation_decision | material | Do not transfer an ordinary account link. | unresolved

Historical relationship unresolved (XW_0012)

application_level_relationship | no recovered startup token or call path | historical_relationship_unresolved | application-level identification only; no species-account link | Physical asset unresolved.

Contextual comment (HRO_0016)

A clean single-bird recording played at application startup; it was not the concept-page audio and not MC1, MC2, MC3, or MC4. | contextual_comment | not_identified | application_level_only

Excluded candidate (HRO_0018)

100.WAV / 441001.WAV | 100.WAV / 441001.WAV excluded as the startup recording. | excluded_candidate | definite | excluded_candidate

Manifest verification limitation (CU_0010)

The verified-normalized checksum file includes a checksum for itself that does not match; all other listed entries validated. | modern_reconciliation_decision | documentation | Recorded only; protected package not modified. | unresolved

Other (HRO_SCAN_0002)

Molothrus ater | Deleted/crossed-out taxon string | other | not_identified | deleted_evidence_no_active_identification | Preserved as deletion; no active identification row is created from the name.

Illegible transcription (CU_SCAN_0001)

P1-U03 contains illegible crossed-out top-right pen marks. | transcription | documentation | Remain [illegible]; no observation inferred. | unresolved

Ambiguous transcription (CU_SCAN_0004)

P1-U30 reads SNCXFR11; definite owner mapping resolves SNLXFR11.MP3. | transcription | material | Preserve SNCXFR11 diplomatically; mapping remains separate. | resolved_mapping_transcription_remains_ambiguous

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Ferruginous Antbird species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

No historical label (XW_SCAN_0012)

no_historical_label | no recovered descriptive metadata | no_historical_label | Do not create a historical relationship. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0004)

designated_target_species | CRYPTURELLUS NOCTIVAGUS | agrees | Direct listening evidence stored separately. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0005)

contextual_WITH_species | TROGON VIRIDIS | agrees | Historical contextual role retained. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0010)

yellow-legged tinamou. | Yellow-legged Tinamou | species_identification | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0011)

white-tailed trogon | White-tailed Trogon | species_identification | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Multiple birds (HRO_SCAN_0012)

At least two named birds | multiple_birds | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Other (HRO_SCAN_0003)

Deleted/crossed-out 441003 block | other | not_identified | deleted_evidence_no_active_identification | Approximately reads Trogon viridis, yellow-legged Tinamou; this row is non-active evidence only.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Crossed out evidence (CU_SCAN_0006)

Crossed-out 441003 block approximately reads Trogon viridis, yellow-legged Tinamou. | handwritten_original | material | Deleted evidence only; no active identification created from the block. | resolved_disposition

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0014)

contextual_WITH_species | HABIA RUBICA | agrees | Contextual role retained; no owner link. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0016)

contextual_WITH_species | CHAMAEZA MERULOIDES | agrees | Contextual role retained; no owner link. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0017)

contextual_WITH_species | GRALLARIA VARIA | agrees | Contextual role retained; no owner link. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0015)

contextual_WITH_species | TROGON VIRIDIS | agrees | Contextual role retained; no owner link. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0024)

white-tailed trogon | White-tailed Trogon | species_identification | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Unresolved additional bird (CU_SCAN_0008)

MC2 includes an unidentified additional component. | handwritten_original | material | Remain unidentified. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Unidentified additional bird (HRO_SCAN_0025)

Additional unidentified bird/component | unidentified_additional_bird | not_identified | remain_unidentified

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Multiple birds (HRO_SCAN_0028)

Multiple named birds plus an unidentified component | multiple_birds | definite | preserve_as_overlay

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Such's Antthrush species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.
• Open the Variegated Antpitta species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Not identified (CU_SCAN_0009)

441006 is marked only with a question mark. | handwritten_original | material | Remain unidentified; historical target unchanged. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Black-hooded Antwren species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Cannot compare (XW_SCAN_0007)

designated_target_species | FORMICIVORA ERYTHRONOTOS | cannot_compare | Scan leaves identification unknown. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Black-hooded Antwren species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0014)

Unidentified | species_identification | not_identified | remain_unidentified

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Black-hooded Antwren species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Not identified (CU_SCAN_0010)

unknown3 is marked only with a question mark. | handwritten_original | material | Remain unidentified. | unresolved

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0021)

Unidentified | species_identification | not_identified | remain_unidentified

Not identified (CU_SCAN_0011)

unknown1 is marked only with a question mark. | handwritten_original | material | Remain unidentified; historical status retained. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Sepia-capped Flycatcher species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0013)

unidentified_recording_status | UNKNW1 unidentified historical recording | agrees | Unidentified status retained. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Sepia-capped Flycatcher species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0022)

Unidentified | species_identification | not_identified | preserve_historical_unidentified_status

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Sepia-capped Flycatcher species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Not identified (CU_SCAN_0012)

H6380SO is marked only with a question mark. | handwritten_original | material | Remain unidentified. | unresolved

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0029)

Unidentified | species_identification | not_identified | remain_unidentified

Not identified (CU_SCAN_0013)

MC4 has two question marks; exact semantic/component count is unresolved. | handwritten_original | material | Remain unidentified; do not infer exactly two birds. | unresolved

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Cannot compare (XW_SCAN_0019)

contextual_recording | historical contextual mixed-flock record | cannot_compare | Scan remains unidentified. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0031)

Unidentified; exact component count unresolved | species_identification | not_identified | remain_unidentified | Two marks do not establish exactly two birds.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

Partially agrees (XW_SCAN_0003)

designated_target_species | MERULAXIS ATER | partially_agrees | Handwriting is genus-level only. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording
• Open the Slaty Bristlefront species page Background only. This is not a resolution of the record above.

Species identification (HRO_SCAN_0006)

Merulaxis | Merulaxis | species_identification | definite | preserve_as_overlay | Genus-level only; not promoted to Merulaxis ater.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

We have deliberately not treated this note as naming this bird, so its page is not linked here. The note gives a group of birds, not a single species, and we have kept it that way.

Agrees (XW_SCAN_0006)

designated_target_species | SALTATOR SIMILIS | agrees | Historical target retained. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Other pages on this site that mention these records. None of them is a resolution of the entry above.

• Open the Introduction page that discusses this recording

No historical label (XW_SCAN_0018)

no_historical_label | physical asset only | no_historical_label | Direct review does not create a historical source relation or startup relation. | Human review is an overlay and never creates or transfers historical ownership.

Multiple birds (HRO_0003)

Both historically linked species are audible. | multiple_birds | definite | retain_both_historical_links | Confirmed multi-species recording; not a duplicate-link error.

Multiple birds (HRO_0006)

Both historically linked species are audible. | multiple_birds | definite | retain_both_historical_links | Confirmed multi-species recording; not a duplicate-link error.